Paul Holmes: Good Riddance

paulholmesThere’s been a lot of ridiculous eulogising of Mr Holmes in the media following his untimely passing.  Let me offer a rebuttal:

Paul Holmes destroyed current affairs television in New Zealand.  He trivialised it to the point where it meant nothing.  He took it from a place where reporters investigated stories to one where it became about “human interest”, feelings over facts, and cats up trees.  He was all style and no substance.  Worst of all, he made the stories about him, rather than finding out what was really going on.  While it has to be said that this formed part of a general worldwide trend in journalism, he was the one that spearheaded it in New Zealand.

The worst aspect of his show was that he had no clue how to interview a subject.  Invariably his “questions” would involve him talking at length, explaining the situation to viewers as he saw it, then asking the interviewee if he or she agreed.  Most of the time these people would be embarrassed enough to bloviate a little.  Occasionally, someone would call Holmes out on his bullshit and simply give a yes or no answer, leaving awkward dead air and a shuffling of desk papers as Holmes ambled back on through the silence in his classic, egotistical style.  The end result was that one was normally left knowing less about the interview subject and more about Mr Holmes.

Apparently enough people found this entertaining such that it kept his show on air.  Personally, I never understood his appeal.

On the other hand, it has to be said that he was an excellent talkback host, and one of the pioneers of that field in New Zealand.  It’s a shame he didn’t stay with what he was good at.  He was also one of the few media figures who tended to veer right, at least on some issues.  So there were some positive aspects to him.  But these do not merit the ridiculous fawning and slobbering over his corpse which has taken place in recent days.  The likes of which may be his ultimate legacy – the media are simply following that dreadful blueprint left behind by the departed.

5 thoughts on “Paul Holmes: Good Riddance

  1. Lindsay says:

    Sometimes I suspect you are rudely contrary for the sake of it. Some of your post content is fair enough but the title is nasty.

  2. In death, as in life, he outwore his welcome. Perhaps the title is nasty, but I’m not being contrary for the sake of it. I’ve disliked his show and his broadcasting style for years. I don’t blog to repeat what everybody else is saying – not most of the time anyway.

  3. Paranormal says:

    Couldn’t agree more Blair.

    One interview in particular comes to mind. A certain high profile individuals’ luxury launch had been stolen. The claim had been declined so Holmes called in the insurance coy CEO. The interview was fiesty with Holmes swearing – Fing and blinding and carrying on. The CEO reacted to that. What appeared on Holmes that night was a carefully edited thing with Holmes asking caring questions in a genuine way (obviously shot after the fact) and the CEO reacting big time. It came out later, when the boat was recovered from Rangi channel, that the owner had had it ‘stolen’ and sunk for the insurance money. Not a peep of apology or even an update from the poison dwarf.

    As always with Holmes it was all about Holmes.

  4. Raider580 says:

    `Could not agree more, did not see most of his career but recall an election night when he and Lindsay Perigo were fronting the TV coverage. Had no clue as to what was happening and could not string to words together let alone a sentence. Never cease to amaze how people get jobs and keep them.

  5. Tracey says:

    Yes Good riddance.Waste of space.I cannot believe he called himself a Journalist.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: